Sherwin Williams vs Menards – Which Holds Better Painting Products?

Trying to choose the best paint for your next project? You’re in the right place. Two favourites in the painting community are Sherwin Williams and Menards. However, it can be difficult to choose the right one. That’s why in today’s blog post, we’ll be comparing Sherwin Williams vs Menards so you can make the best purchasing decision.

What is Sherwin Williams?

Sherwin Williams

Sherwin Williams is a major paint company that provides painting products for professionals and homeowners. They have been in business for over 150 years with their headquarters located in Cleveland, Ohio.

They offer the following products:

  • Paint: Paints, stains, primers, and paint for specific applications like aerospace and cars.
  • Wallpaper: They provide wallpapers to complete your home decorating project or makeover.
  • Tools & Accessories: Rollers, brushes, edgers, pan scrapers and other tools you need to complete a high quality painting job.

Sherwin Williams carries brands like Valspar, Minwax, Purdy, Krylon, Dutch Boy, Dupli-Color, and others.

They are well received among their customers, sporting hundreds of reviews on Consumer Affairs and other websites. As you can see from these reviews, customers enjoy Sherwin Williams paint products for its easy application and quality.

Sherwin Williams reviews

That brings us to their competitor, Menards.

What is Menards?


Menards is a chain of home improvement stores with locations in the United States, Canada. They have been around since 1962 and they are based out of Eau Claire, WI.

They offer a much wider variety of products for painters, such as:

  • Paints, stains, sealers, and additives.
  • Building materials like drywall and lumber.
  • Flooring, rugs, and other décor.
  • Appliances and hardware.
  • And more!

This is convenient if you need other products than just paint. After all, you might be painting the interior of your home and decide to add a new backsplash or floor tiles in the kitchen for example. In that case, Menards is a great choice.

The company also has a great online reputation with hundreds of positive reviews on platforms like Consumer Affairs. As you can see from these reviews, customers enjoy Menards customer service and product selection.

Menards reviews

Sherwin Williams paint quality

Okay, let’s talk about the next important thing: quality. How good is Sherwin Williams paint?

Sherwin Williams is a good retailer for most people. Since they carry a wide variety of brands, they offer excellent quality at an affordable price. Sherwin Williams colors are also really nice and their paints usually have some pretty interesting “designer” options like flat look or metallic sheen. They’re a great option if you want to buy prestige without paying too much money.

Overall, this is one of the better brands on the market right now because it offers both affordability and high-quality products with fun features like colour palettes and finishes so there’s something for everyone. They use premium pigments that result in rich colors and a lot of variety as well.

Sherwin Williams paint price

How much do you have to dish out to buy Sherwin Williams paint? Well, it depends on the exact product you purchase. I.e. interior paint, primer, etc. However, here are some examples from their website. As you can see, prices for interior paint range from $50-75/gallon.

Sherwin Williams pricing

Let’s talk more about Menards paint products next.

Menards paint quality

Menards hold similar brands to Sherwin Williams among others like Rust-Oleum, Pittsburgh Paints & Stains, Lucite, Grand Distinction, and Conco. Because of this, the paint quality of Menards is high because you have a wide selection to choose from. Need something frugal? No problem. Need high-end paint for a luxury home? Menards has products that will help with that too.

Menards paint price

Since we looked at the pricing of Sherwin Williams interior paint, let’s do the same for Menards. Visiting their website, we can see that Menards paint is priced much more competitively at approximately $20/gallon.

Menards pricing

They also offer a wider variety of brands, giving you more options versus Sherwin Williams only seeing their own product line.

Final thoughts on Sherwin Williams vs Menards

Choosing the right type of paint can be difficult. You don’t want to waste your money and time by selecting the wrong one. Two of the most popular choices are Sherwin Williams and Menards.

We recommend Sherwin Williams for homeowners and painters that have a bigger budget and require just paint. Menard, on the other hand, is ideal for budget conscious painters and those who need other products like flooring, outdoors, and tools.

Need professional painters to bring your dream home to life in the Calgary area? Contact us for a free quote.

Pamela Vigneault
Pamela Vigneault
We hired Earl and his crew to paint the baseboards & walls of our basement. He is very good at answering emails and texts. Also is punctual when meeting for quotes and doing the work. I specifically wanted our baseboards lacquered and NOT brush or roller painted. It cost more, but the results speak for themselves. The basement was left clean and the furniture well covered. Great work from this company. Would recommend
Lorraine Townsend
Lorraine Townsend
Recently Earl painted the exterior of our house. The structure was very challenging and needed an enormous amount of prep work. Earl and his crew showed up every day on time and went full tilt for 4 days to get all the prep and painting done. The paint was all brushed and rolled.They were very professional and it was obvious that they take pride in their work.I did have trouble deciding on the colours and after a couple of stressful months, I followed up with a colour consultant that Earl recommended. It was money well spent and we are very pleased with how it turned out.I would not hesitate to recommend Earl and his crew.
Earl and his team helped me dramatically improve the interior of a recently purchased 1960 Bungalow. They prepped and painted the main level completely (ceiling, walls, windows, door jams, etc.) and did some painting in basement as well. Easy to work with from the start to finish. Great job, on time, and at a reasonable price. I highly recommend Earl’s Paintworks. I will most likely be using their services again soon!
Jenn Balderston
Jenn Balderston
Earl is the best in the business! We hired Earl to paint the exterior of our 106 year-old heritage home that was in disrepair. Our house is a craftsman bungalow that required highly detailed workmanship. Because of the uniqueness of the house, and its heritage value, we were nervous to hire the job out to just anyone. We met with a number of companies and Earl's Paintworks stood tall above the rest. We loved that Earl was an owner/operator and knew after talking to him that he'd take great care with our beloved home. We weren't wrong! Earl and Jeremy were meticulous - sanding every nook and cranny to ensure a perfect finish that would stand the test of time. We wanted a tri-colour scheme to show off the home's craftsmanship, which required a lot of taping, cutting, and intricate work. Our neighbours would stop by to compliment Earl and Jeremy - blown away by the precision and quality of their work. Both my fiancé and I were sad to see them leave. Earl and Jeremy had become fast friends, always making time to stop and visit with us (despite putting in long days of hard labour). Couldn't recommend them enough! If you are looking for a painter, do yourself a favour, and stop here.
Julie Sontag
Julie Sontag
We recently hired Earl's Paintworks to repaint the entire interior of a newly-purchased home and could not be more pleased with the quality of the work and exceptional service provided from start to finish. We were on a very tight timeline & Earl (the owner) and Jeremy showed up ready to work 30 minutes after we took possession of the house. They put in long hours to finish the job in only 8.5 days, despite the fact that it was a massive project (3 storey house with over 30 windows/doors to paint around and some 20ft ceilings). The care they took to cover our hardwood floors, carpeting and cabinetry was remarkable - not a drop of paint left anywhere it didn't belong.Earl was truly a pleasure to work with, responded to our questions in a timely & friendly fashion, and provided knowledgeable (and realistic) advice on different finishes and colour options. He even went above and beyond to point out some small repairs that needed to be addressed around the house which was helpful to us as new owners. We had 4 different companies quote on the job and chose Earl's Paintworks based on a gut feeling that Earl was the right choice. Very happy with our decision - so much so that we're hoping to have them back this summer to do the exterior of our house as well.We would recommend Earl's Paintworks to anyone without hesitation. If you're looking for a hardworking, locally-owned company to do an efficient, professional, super high quality job, this is it!
Ken Cheung
Ken Cheung
We wanted the interior and doors repainted in our home in preparation for selling. We obtained a couple of quotes from painters. We ended up choosing Earl due to our positive interactions with him.This is a small but very professional company. It was good to work with a smaller company where the person painting your home is the actual owner and therefore, someone who took full responsibility for the work. Earl was very helpful with colour suggestions. He was easy to communicate with via both emails, phone calls and text. Earl was a perfectionist. He finished our 2 level 2000 sq ft home in about 6 full days. He came a few weeks later to do the exterior doors (garage and entry) when the weather was warmer.I would not hesitate to recommend Earl's Paintworks.